Catholic / Orthodox Relations
John Paul II's Icon Arrives in Kazan, but Dialogue with Catholics Remains Difficult
AsiaNews, 7/20/2005
Russia - Aleksij II, Patriarch of Moscow and all the Russias, will deliver to Kazan the historic icon of the Mother of God, donated last year to the Russian Orthodox Church by John Paul II, AsiaNews was told today by Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin, the deputy head of the Department for foreign relations of the Moscow Patriarchate.
Chaplin points out however
that it is not a question of a "return", as "the Patriarch will simply bring
to Kazan a copy of the original icon, the great symbolic value of which is
nevertheless undisputed."
Aleksij II arrived today in the capital of Tatarstan, a region of the
Russian Federation situated in the middle of the Volga basin, to participate
in the celebrations for the 450th anniversary of the founding of the Kazan
Eparchy. Tomorrow, in the Cathedral of the Annunciation Monastery, he will
preside a solemn celebration for the feast of the "apparition of the Mother
of God icon," which falls right on July 21. The icon will be taken in
procession from the Kremlin (the city's fortress) to the monastery. A
special bullet-proof display case is ready to receive the icon, but it is
still not clear where it will be located. Alexander Pavlov of the Kazan
Eparchy's press office explained that the "icon must be accessible to the
faithful, but the Cathedral of the Annunciation (Editor's note: due to
restoration works) will be open to the public only at Easter and Christmas."
Chaplin pointed out to AsiaNews that "until the completion of restoration
works, the icon will be kept in a location yet to be announced." According
to the local press, the icon will be displayed for a few days in the
Cathedral of the Annunciation - which originally housed the image - and will
be later moved temporarily to the Church of Saints Peter and Paul."
Kazan authorities had for some time been asking for the miraculous image's
return to the city. Patriarch Aleksij II felt the gesture was "premature",
given that conditions in Kazan did not allow for a worthy reception of the
icon. During the Soviet period, the Monastery of the Annunciation had been
used as a tobacco factory and the Cathedral became the site of a university.
"At this point," Chaplin explains, "Kazan authorities have delivered on
their promises." Recently, the mayor, Kamil Ischakov, gave instructions for
a new plot of land to be assigned to the factory, while restoration to the
Cathedral has already begun.
Representatives of other religious confessions will also take part in the
celebrations. "There will certainly be figures from the Muslim community,
with whom we have good relations of cohabitation; I cannot say if Catholic
representatives will be present."
Almost a year has past since the sacred imagine was returned to Russia (Pope
John Paul II had donated it to the Russian Orthodox Church last August 28th)
and, in view of the latest efforts by the Catholic Church for unity with
Moscow, Archpriest Chaplin "does not think that the shared devotion to Our
Lady can help improve relations between the two Churches." "The required
preliminary condition," he reiterated, "is that the Vatican put an end to
proselytism in Russia: this alone can open the doors for a real
rapprochement." The Archpriest does recognize, nevertheless, progress in
relations and stated, "We are in constant dialogue to put an end to
competition in the spheres of influence and to give way to cooperation, but
efforts must be bilateral."
© AsiaNews